Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Unfortunately it does not help by pointing out what to look for in order to recognise the real thing.
Does anyone know if the stamps shown below are real or forged?
Login to Like
this post
Hi Jansimon,
I have a copy (PDF) of the "Sérane" for fake and forgery" if you can find a copy of this book, in page "53" in "SOUDAN" they give some clue but no image... the also tell to look in the "French Colonies" for the same type of false overprint. I try to copy and paste my PDF but I am not able to do it., I have to leave the house but in few hours I will have time to copy it in this discusion board... if you still need it...
see you later,
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
This overprint is listed in the Fournier Album but no details. Here's a link to the page.
http://www.geocities.com/claghorn1p/FournierAlbum/164.htm
Ross
Login to Like
this post
I have the same problem, but at least I can identify the blatant fakes..here the two Inverted O/P. In the second photo, there is a mix of real and counterfeit, by my opinion, and I look at the spacing between letters (U and D in particular) and the spacing between arabic and latin characters, as well as the alignment of the two lines. My guess; my #4 and #5 are fakes, and the others are probably genuine (#2 is doubtful).
But there are really good fakes as well!
rrr...
Login to Like
this post
Jansimon, can you read easely the french language ?? if so I will copy the "Sérane" text about the SUDAN, if not I can try to translate....
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
As I understand the "SÉRANE" explanation, it's by comparing the stamps.... that you can see the differences,the main thing said in this book is that the false overprint have been made at GENEVA on original used stamps with Egypt cancellation....
In French, we read:
"SOUDAN ÉGYPTIEN
1897. Surchargés SOUDAN nos. 1 à 8. Fausses surcharges : comparaison nécessaire. Toute la série existe faussement surchargée à Genève sur timbres originaux oblitérés d’Égypte."
hope it's help a little....
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
Hi Jacques,
Merci beaucoup! I understand French enough to read it. Speaking is more difficult. I suppose the real challenge with these overprints is finding real ones that can be used as a benchmark...
Login to Like
this post
Jan and all...Here is an image of a good one auction # 3933, to compare to.
http://stampauctionnetwork.com/rs/rs101157.cfm
Mike in NC / meostamps
Login to Like
this post
This stampboard posting has a page from an old catalogue with info on the overprint
http://www.stampcommunity.org/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=12129&whichpage=2
Mike in NC / meostamps
Login to Like
this post
This is a set that remains on my list of "things to look into later".
Several different fakes exist. The fakes outnumber the genuine, but as with the Persian stamps, you can usually expect a mix of genuine and fakes in the same batch (my opinion, no statistical evidence to back it up).
You have to be little careful when comparing to a known genuine stamp. You might be able to confirm it is genuine, but just because it doesn't look exactly the same doesn't mean it is a fake. Genuine overprints come in 6 types, and there is more than one setting, not to mention varieties that have been confirmed as genuine. If you really want to get into it (I wish I had the time and the health), you might want to consider the Sudan Study Group.
k
Login to Like
this post
On Ralph's stamps, I agree #4 and #5 are fakes, in addition to the 2 inverted overprints. I would say #1 is likely a fake as well (or maybe a genuine type/variety I am unaware of), and #2 looks suspicious. On those 2 stamps (and on cancelled stamps in general), you can check to see if the cancel is over or beneath the overprint. My non-expert opinion, as I haven't really studied these overprint/fake history in detail.
Login to Like
this post
Ralph's #2 has a cancel "...OUM" - that might be KHARTOUM in the Sudan. I think this is very difficult and confusing.
Login to Like
this post
Thanks Kim:
Not sure about #2...but also not sure about #1, since the cancellation is on top of the O/P..so I still think "genuine"...but I do hear you!
#3 seems to be the only clearly genuine one...and I happen to have 2 samples, with the second one clearly a counterfeit, as the o/p sit visibly on top of the cancellation...I just did not post a picture, but can if anyone is intrigued.
I have been looking for the 1-8 Sudan stamps for a while, but won't pay the price without a certificate, and most of what I see at auction and on the internet is just worth nothing like the asking prices (unless you specialize in counterfeit).
This brought me back to some Lebanon stamps I labeled as fakes, but now I think it may be a paper variety, post world war II, but there is no mention of it in my sources... I will start a new thread on the topic, and would appreciate any comments.
Rrr...
Login to Like
this post
Since the fake overprints are applied to previously cancelled stamps, I wonder: Are any of the affordably-priced USB microscopes of high enough resolution to be able to discern if the overprint ink lies atop the cancellation ink?
Ted
Login to Like
this post
I would say that the 1st 13 stamps are genuine. They are reasonably common and there are several settings. The postmarks, when reasonably clear, give a good indication. They are listed in standard catalogues.
Login to Like
this post
Approvals
The Scott catalogue mentions "Counterfeits of Nos. 1-8 are plentiful.".
Unfortunately it does not help by pointing out what to look for in order to recognise the real thing.
Does anyone know if the stamps shown below are real or forged?
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Hi Jansimon,
I have a copy (PDF) of the "Sérane" for fake and forgery" if you can find a copy of this book, in page "53" in "SOUDAN" they give some clue but no image... the also tell to look in the "French Colonies" for the same type of false overprint. I try to copy and paste my PDF but I am not able to do it., I have to leave the house but in few hours I will have time to copy it in this discusion board... if you still need it...
see you later,
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
To error is human -to really fowl things up takes a computer
14 Oct 2013
11:13:23am
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
This overprint is listed in the Fournier Album but no details. Here's a link to the page.
http://www.geocities.com/claghorn1p/FournierAlbum/164.htm
Ross
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
I have the same problem, but at least I can identify the blatant fakes..here the two Inverted O/P. In the second photo, there is a mix of real and counterfeit, by my opinion, and I look at the spacing between letters (U and D in particular) and the spacing between arabic and latin characters, as well as the alignment of the two lines. My guess; my #4 and #5 are fakes, and the others are probably genuine (#2 is doubtful).
But there are really good fakes as well!
rrr...
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Jansimon, can you read easely the french language ?? if so I will copy the "Sérane" text about the SUDAN, if not I can try to translate....
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
As I understand the "SÉRANE" explanation, it's by comparing the stamps.... that you can see the differences,the main thing said in this book is that the false overprint have been made at GENEVA on original used stamps with Egypt cancellation....
In French, we read:
"SOUDAN ÉGYPTIEN
1897. Surchargés SOUDAN nos. 1 à 8. Fausses surcharges : comparaison nécessaire. Toute la série existe faussement surchargée à Genève sur timbres originaux oblitérés d’Égypte."
hope it's help a little....
Jacques
Login to Like
this post
Approvals
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Hi Jacques,
Merci beaucoup! I understand French enough to read it. Speaking is more difficult. I suppose the real challenge with these overprints is finding real ones that can be used as a benchmark...
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Jan and all...Here is an image of a good one auction # 3933, to compare to.
http://stampauctionnetwork.com/rs/rs101157.cfm
Mike in NC / meostamps
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
This stampboard posting has a page from an old catalogue with info on the overprint
http://www.stampcommunity.org/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=12129&whichpage=2
Mike in NC / meostamps
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
This is a set that remains on my list of "things to look into later".
Several different fakes exist. The fakes outnumber the genuine, but as with the Persian stamps, you can usually expect a mix of genuine and fakes in the same batch (my opinion, no statistical evidence to back it up).
You have to be little careful when comparing to a known genuine stamp. You might be able to confirm it is genuine, but just because it doesn't look exactly the same doesn't mean it is a fake. Genuine overprints come in 6 types, and there is more than one setting, not to mention varieties that have been confirmed as genuine. If you really want to get into it (I wish I had the time and the health), you might want to consider the Sudan Study Group.
k
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
On Ralph's stamps, I agree #4 and #5 are fakes, in addition to the 2 inverted overprints. I would say #1 is likely a fake as well (or maybe a genuine type/variety I am unaware of), and #2 looks suspicious. On those 2 stamps (and on cancelled stamps in general), you can check to see if the cancel is over or beneath the overprint. My non-expert opinion, as I haven't really studied these overprint/fake history in detail.
Login to Like
this post
Approvals
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Ralph's #2 has a cancel "...OUM" - that might be KHARTOUM in the Sudan. I think this is very difficult and confusing.
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Thanks Kim:
Not sure about #2...but also not sure about #1, since the cancellation is on top of the O/P..so I still think "genuine"...but I do hear you!
#3 seems to be the only clearly genuine one...and I happen to have 2 samples, with the second one clearly a counterfeit, as the o/p sit visibly on top of the cancellation...I just did not post a picture, but can if anyone is intrigued.
I have been looking for the 1-8 Sudan stamps for a while, but won't pay the price without a certificate, and most of what I see at auction and on the internet is just worth nothing like the asking prices (unless you specialize in counterfeit).
This brought me back to some Lebanon stamps I labeled as fakes, but now I think it may be a paper variety, post world war II, but there is no mention of it in my sources... I will start a new thread on the topic, and would appreciate any comments.
Rrr...
Login to Like
this post
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
Since the fake overprints are applied to previously cancelled stamps, I wonder: Are any of the affordably-priced USB microscopes of high enough resolution to be able to discern if the overprint ink lies atop the cancellation ink?
Ted
Login to Like
this post
08:48:42pm
re: Sudan overprint of Egyptian stamps: real or fake
I would say that the 1st 13 stamps are genuine. They are reasonably common and there are several settings. The postmarks, when reasonably clear, give a good indication. They are listed in standard catalogues.
Login to Like
this post