Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
I'm working on US revenues. I have several Battleships. The catalog tells me they could be Rouletted 5 1/2 or Hyphen Hole Perf 7. I understand both terms. Is there a picture somewhere out on the internet that can show me the real difference?
Here's the stamp in question:
Thanks for your help,
Luree
Login to Like
this post
Your stamp is roulette 5.5.
In hyphen-hole, paper is actually removed during the perforation process. Also, the gauge would be 7. Turns out on these revenues, you can just count the "nubs" on the side and figure out whether 5.5 or 7.
I'll see if I can make and upload a comparative pic for you.
Login to Like
this post
Thanks k, you are the best. What confused me is on the side I did count 5.5, but the top is hyphens, or what looks like hyphen to me. So what I need to do is just count the right hand side for the rouletting?
l
Login to Like
this post
Working on the picture...
Always count the right/left side for this issue.
Those are actually roulettes, but it does look like hyphens. In hyphen-hole, the slits (i.e., hyphens are actually cut out long rectangles. If you look are both the top AND the bottom of your stamp, you will realize what has happened. In the separation process, the paper did not tear perfectly in the middle, so you see "nubs" at the bottom and "divots" at the top where the paper tore out.
See my pic in the next post and you may see it more clearly.
Login to Like
this post
The 1c is roulette 5.5 and the 2c is hypen-hole 7. Don't be misled by the left-over nubbies on the roulette 5.5.
I'll try to post a picture of unseparated stamps.
Login to Like
this post
OK, 0.5c is roulette and 5c is hyphen-hole. Notice in the roulette, no paper is removed during the cutting process. In the hyphen-hole, a thin rectangular strip (i.e., hyphen) is removed.
Obviously, easier to see when still connected. If you know the roul/perf gauge, sometimes it's easier to just measure/count it.
Login to Like
this post
Thank you, I see the difference now. It just makes it so much easier to know what I should be looking at instead of guessing.
Login to Like
this post
Here is an example of serious hyphen hole perforation:
Login to Like
this post
terry, are those Shermack perfs?
Login to Like
this post
Why, yes.....
Those are "Shermack" perforations. They are a type of hypen hole perforation. Shermack was one company invested in stamp vending machines between 1905 and 1920. They applied their perforations primarily to strips of stamps from imperforate sheets, to make the stamps easier to detach from the output feed of the vending machines.
Another company into the private stamp vending machine business was Attleboro. Their hyphen hole perforation was even more severe:
This is the backside of a pair of the Alaska-Yukon issue (Scott 371) with Attleboro private perforations.
Interesting stuff, huh?!
Login to Like
this post
Great information. May I suggest to edit better title so that the information can be easier retrieved in the future? Perhaps "Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?" -- or whatever you prefer, but not "Can somebody tell me....":
"Please choose a descriptive title for new discussions you start whenever possible. An informative subject line stating the main key words is not only a courtesy to other members, who wish to know what the discussion is about, but also ensures that discussions can be readily located in the future using our search function"
(Modified by Moderator on 2013-05-02 13:02:36)
Login to Like
this post
Sorry I didn't follow your rules on the subject line......
But for those who did reply, I do thank you for the information
Login to Like
this post
11:53:28am
Purrfin2 - No need to apologize! We all appreciate titles that are as complete as possible but there is a learning curve. No worries 
Login to Like
this post
APS #222602 and Internet Philatelic Dealers Association #439
01 May 2013
05:26:29pm
Approvals
I'm off to yet another part of stamps that I haven't been through and can not find the answer to my question or at least a picture so I can see the difference.
I'm working on US revenues. I have several Battleships. The catalog tells me they could be Rouletted 5 1/2 or Hyphen Hole Perf 7. I understand both terms. Is there a picture somewhere out on the internet that can show me the real difference?
Here's the stamp in question:
Thanks for your help,
Luree
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Your stamp is roulette 5.5.
In hyphen-hole, paper is actually removed during the perforation process. Also, the gauge would be 7. Turns out on these revenues, you can just count the "nubs" on the side and figure out whether 5.5 or 7.
I'll see if I can make and upload a comparative pic for you.
Login to Like
this post
APS #222602 and Internet Philatelic Dealers Association #439
01 May 2013
05:55:46pm
Approvals
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Thanks k, you are the best. What confused me is on the side I did count 5.5, but the top is hyphens, or what looks like hyphen to me. So what I need to do is just count the right hand side for the rouletting?
l
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Working on the picture...
Always count the right/left side for this issue.
Those are actually roulettes, but it does look like hyphens. In hyphen-hole, the slits (i.e., hyphens are actually cut out long rectangles. If you look are both the top AND the bottom of your stamp, you will realize what has happened. In the separation process, the paper did not tear perfectly in the middle, so you see "nubs" at the bottom and "divots" at the top where the paper tore out.
See my pic in the next post and you may see it more clearly.
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
The 1c is roulette 5.5 and the 2c is hypen-hole 7. Don't be misled by the left-over nubbies on the roulette 5.5.
I'll try to post a picture of unseparated stamps.
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
OK, 0.5c is roulette and 5c is hyphen-hole. Notice in the roulette, no paper is removed during the cutting process. In the hyphen-hole, a thin rectangular strip (i.e., hyphen) is removed.
Obviously, easier to see when still connected. If you know the roul/perf gauge, sometimes it's easier to just measure/count it.
Login to Like
this post
APS #222602 and Internet Philatelic Dealers Association #439
01 May 2013
06:23:04pm
Approvals
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Thank you, I see the difference now. It just makes it so much easier to know what I should be looking at instead of guessing.
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Here is an example of serious hyphen hole perforation:
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
terry, are those Shermack perfs?
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Why, yes.....
Those are "Shermack" perforations. They are a type of hypen hole perforation. Shermack was one company invested in stamp vending machines between 1905 and 1920. They applied their perforations primarily to strips of stamps from imperforate sheets, to make the stamps easier to detach from the output feed of the vending machines.
Another company into the private stamp vending machine business was Attleboro. Their hyphen hole perforation was even more severe:
This is the backside of a pair of the Alaska-Yukon issue (Scott 371) with Attleboro private perforations.
Interesting stuff, huh?!
Login to Like
this post
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Great information. May I suggest to edit better title so that the information can be easier retrieved in the future? Perhaps "Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?" -- or whatever you prefer, but not "Can somebody tell me....":
"Please choose a descriptive title for new discussions you start whenever possible. An informative subject line stating the main key words is not only a courtesy to other members, who wish to know what the discussion is about, but also ensures that discussions can be readily located in the future using our search function"
(Modified by Moderator on 2013-05-02 13:02:36)
Login to Like
this post
APS #222602 and Internet Philatelic Dealers Association #439
03 May 2013
07:46:11am
Approvals
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Sorry I didn't follow your rules on the subject line......
But for those who did reply, I do thank you for the information
Login to Like
this post
It is during our darkest moments that we must focus to see the light. - Aristotle Onassis
05 May 2013
11:53:28am
re: Revenues: Roulette or Hyphen Hole Perforation?
Purrfin2 - No need to apologize! We all appreciate titles that are as complete as possible but there is a learning curve. No worries
Login to Like
this post