What we collect!

 

Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps



What we collect!
What we collect!


General Philatelic/Gen. Discussion : 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

 

Author
Postings
michael78651

09 May 2016
01:22:31am
This thread contains my review of a catalog value comparison between the 2015 Scott catalogs and the 2017 Scott Catalogs. It is strictly a comparison of values of the stamps in my personal collection. If you were to do the same thing as what I am doing here, your results may be different if your collection is made up differently than mine. An example would be that most of my Czechoslovakia is primarily mint, never hinged and almost complete. If you collect Czechoslovakia, but it is primarily used incomplete sets and only 35% complete, you may see different results if you did this review.

As I list the various countries, in Scott order unless specified otherwise, I will add some comments of possible interest to let you know what I have found. If the comparison of a country doesn't offer much, then there will not be much if any special notes.

There is one rule with this thread, do NOT post comments on this thread. Comments will make it difficult for others to see the reviews as I post them. Any comments posted here will be deleted. You've been warned, so don't complain if you post and it is deleted.

You are welcome to post all the comments you want on the catalog review post thread.

Thanks for everyone's cooperation, and enjoy the reviews.
Like 
5 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

09 May 2016
01:31:59am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

SCOTT CATALOG VOLUME I

United States +0.3%

Stamps from 1922-1925 saw a decrease in never hinged values. From 1980 onward values for booklets, booklet panes and booklet singles are generally down. Definitive stamps from 2000 and 2001 increased in value. The imperf Bugs Bunny sheet saw a nice increase. A large number of stamps issued from 2008-2013 saw increases. The high value Priority and Express mail stamps saw nice increases. All but the last semi-postal stamp increased in value. A few early air mails saw changes, mostly upwards. Confederate States saw no change.

United States: Canal Zone -0.8%

Most of the changes were found in the pre-USA issues. The first USA issue saw increases.

United States: Guam (no change)

United States: Hawaii +4.3%

The only changes, and they were almost all upwards were found in the provisional government overprint issues of 1893.

United States: Ryukyu Islands -5.3%

Values changes, almost all downward, were contained in the stamps issued through 1966. This includes the air mails.

Like 
6 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

09 May 2016
03:34:33pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

United Nations -0.7%

New York: Higher valued sets issued prior to 1988 were down. After 1988 there was not much activity. A few higher valued stamps were either up or down.

Geneva: 1999 Australia souvenir booklet was up. No other changes.

Vienna: 1999 Australia souvenir booklet was up as was the 2006 Indigenous Art sheet.

Abu Dhabi -0.5%

Most of the loss was in the first definitive set.

Aden and States -10.7%

King George VI era stamps were down considerably. Queen Elizabeth II era stamps were generally up, but not enough to offset the losses from her father.

Afghanistan +1.7%

Only changes were in the stamps issued from 1928-1932, and these were almost all increases.

Aguerra, La (no changes)

Aitutaki -0.5%

All changes were in the stamps issued in the 1920s.

Ajman +13.0%

All stamps in MNH condition increased in value.

Alaouites +10.5%

Stamps in the first definitive set increased as did the black overprinted postage due stamps from 1925.

Like 
4 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 May 2016
11:16:41pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Albania -16.5%

Up to 1922 and then after 1946 values were down 20 to 50% or more on many stamps. After 1946 there were some increases, but not nearly enough to overcome the declines.

Alexandretta +13.5%

The air mail set is the only change.

Algeria -0.4%

A wild ride with ups and downs all over the place through 1979, including semi-postal and postage dues. From 1980 onward, especially the 2000s the changes were mostly increases, but not enough to balance the ledger.

Allenstein +5.5%

All changes were with used stamps.

Andorra (Spanish and French) no changes

Angola +1.9%

Angra (no changes)

Anguilla -6.6%

All value changes were up to 2002.

Anjouan no changes

Annam & Tonkin no changes

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

16 May 2016
11:52:38am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Antigua +0.3%

Up to 1930 values are up. After 1930, values are down.

Argentina +0.0%

Many value changes from 1951 on, including semi-postals. All evened out in the end.

Armenia (no change)

Aruba -21.7%

I don't have many stamps from here. What I do have took a deep sea dive, and didn't find any pearls.

Ascension +5.5%

George V increased; George VI increased alot; QEII saw increases and decreases from 1976 on.

Australia -1.0%

Victoria and Western Australia saw no changes. The other states saw some increases and decreases. Australia up to 1930 saw increases. Australian Antarctic Territory pre 2000 decreased, and after 2000 increased.

Austria -0.4%

Little change in the country listings. Offices in Crete saw increases and decreases.

Azerbaijan +0.9%

All changes were in the first set.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 May 2016
10:03:02am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Bahamas +0.3%

Bahrain +2.0%

All changes were before 1953.

Bangkok - no stamps

Bangladesh - no changes

Barbados +2.6%

pre-QEII were increases; QEII were up and down with all up from the 1990s onward.

Barbuda -1.1%

Basutoland -1.0%

Batum +62.7%

Not a typo. Just about everything increased.

Bechuanaland +46.2%

Also not a typo. Many increases prior to QEII, then mixed with mostly increases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

29 May 2016
04:25:19pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Belarus +9.5%

Belgium -0.3%

Increases through the World War II era. Afterwards up to 2005 mostly decreases with many on the large side that wiped out the increases in the older stamps. No change in back-of-book.

Benin (French Colony) -4.8%

Bermuda +1.2%

All changes were prior to 1935.

Bhutan -1.5%

All changes were prior to 1973, including air mails.

Biafra -2.9%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

04 Jun 2016
11:27:47pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Bolivia -12.1%

Value changes from 1946 on show decreases of 50% or more. Includes postage and air mails.

Bosnia & Herzegovina (no change)

Botswana -5.6%

Changes were with the first two definitive sets.

Brazil -0.4%

Almost all changes were up to 1890 and were mostly down.

British Antarctic Territory -5.8%

While other sets saw decreases, the major drop was with the first definitive set.

British Central Africa +2.3%

British East Africa +3.7%

British Guiana +1.5%


Changes were up through 1937.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 Jun 2016
11:59:51am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

British Honduras / Belize +3.1%

Almost all changes were in the Queen Victoria era. A few changes afterwards, including in Belize.

British Indian Ocean Territory +3.0%

First two definitive sets saw increases. After that changes were mostly down.

Brunei +2.1%

All changes were prior to 1949.

Bulgaria +1.0%

All changes were prior to 1953.

Burkina Faso +0.7%

All changes were prior to 1929. Postage dues saw changes as well.

Burma +9.7%

Mixed changes, but many more increases than decreases. The changes covered the British era and afterwards, officials and Japanese occupation.

Burundi -1.7%

Bushire: no stamps from this area.


END OF VOLUME I

Overall total value change for Volume I (not including USA or UN) was -0.2%

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Jun 2016
10:54:23pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

SCOTT CATALOG VOLUME II

Cambodia -0.9%

Cameroun - Cameroons +1.4%

German era was down, British Cameroons was up, French era was mixed.

Canada -0.6%

Provinces were mostly up with some very large increases. Canada was mixed up to 1950 with mostly a downward. From 1977 to 2009 values are down. From 2010 values are mixed. Back of book is mixed.

Cape Juby had no changes

Cape of Good Hope +19.0%

Cape Verde +1.2%

Very small number of changes. See 1886 definitive set and 1962 sports set. Other than that only a couple of other changes.

Caribbean Netherlands no stamps from this area

Caroline Islands had no changes

Castellorizo -16.7%

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

24 Jun 2016
07:58:23pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Cayman Islands +0.1%

All changes were in the Victoria era.

Central African Republic - no changes

Central Lithuania - no changes

Chad +6.9%

Up to 1970 changes were mixed; from around 1995-1999 values were up; semi-postals were up as were air mail (up to 1972), air mail semi-postal and postage dues.

Chile +9.5%

Increases up to 1950 with a few more later on, but not many; air mail and postal tax stamps also increased.

China -8.8%

Large decreases through 1894. No changes in back-of-book, provinces and occupations.

China - People's Republic -8.6%

Up to 1983 changes were mixed with large decreases and some modest increases; Liberation Areas saw no changes.

Christmas Island -6.4%

Up to 1986 almost everything decreased. Those that did not go down had no changes. From 1987 to around 2009, values were mixed; from 2010 onward, values were up, some changes were large, especially for minor catalog numbers. (Remember that my son did this area for 2016-2017 catalog values and saw a 5.5% decrease.)

Cilicia +0.1%

Cochin China - no stamps

Cocos Islands -6.7%

Up to 1986 values were mostly down, especially with the earliest issues and definitive sets, with a few small increases. After that, there were no changes.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

02 Jul 2016
05:26:20pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Colombia +1.3%

All changes were increases and were found in the 1959 to 1970 air mails.

Cook Islands +0.5%

Corfu -15.3%

Costa Rica +0.9%

All changes were increases and were found in the postage and air mail areas for 1990-2002, and postal tax from 1985 onward.

Crete -4.9%

Many changes, both up and down.

Croatia -6.6%

Up to 1994 value changes were mixed; 1943 semi-postals were down; postal tax from 1993-1997 was up.

Cuba +6.0%

All changes, which were mixed, were found in the 19th Century.

Curacao - No stamps from this area.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

15 Jul 2016
05:16:41pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Cyprus +0.7%

Cyrenaica +6.9%

Czechoslovakia +0.9%

Most changes were prior to 1970. Bohemia & Moravia had no changes.

Dahomey / Benin People's Republic -6.1%

Changes in Dahomey were mostly up prior to World War II. Benin PR was mostly up prior to 1980, and then from 1996 onward was down.

- Dalmatia had no changes

Danish West Indies -1.3%

Danzig +1.5%

Denmark +1.5%

Don't let that little percentage increase fool you. There were tons of changes, up and down, large and small throughout the entire listings. Back-of-book material saw some large increases, and I think that is where in the end the net was an overall increase. Without that, I think Denmark would have been down about 2 percentage points.

Diego Suarez -2.0%


Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

23 Jul 2016
12:57:01am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Dominica +3.3% Increases up to 1940; 1940-1970 mixed changes; 1970-1990 values were down; after 1990 no changes.

Dominican Republic -0.1%

Dubai +7.1%

East Africa and Uganda Protectorates +0.9%

Eastern Rumelia no changes

Eastern Silesia no changes

Ecuador -3.1% Changes from 1946-1995, including air mail, were mostly down.

Egypt +0.1%

Elobey, Annobon and Corisco no changes

Epirus +1.8%

Equatorial Guinea no changes

Eritrea +2.5% All changes were in the Italian colonial period.

Estonia no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Aug 2016
07:35:51pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Ethiopia no changes

Falkland Islands +0.4% Victoria through George V saw increases; George VI was mostly increases; QEII was mostly decreases. The dependencies were mostly down.

Far Eastern Republic +5.9%

Faroe Islands no changes

Fernando Po +6.5%

Fiji -0.3% all changes were prior to George VI; postage dues were down

Finland +1.8% While the net overall change is small, the number of changes in this country were vast, and covered all areas. Up to 1950 saw mostly increases with many of them 50% or higher; the 1950s were mixed; from 1960 onward saw mostly decreases many on the large side of 30% to 50%. The Aland Islands saw increases, some large, up to 1993. After that, values were mostly down.

Fiume no changes

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Aug 2016
11:32:42am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

France -2.5% Changes up to 1876 were down; from 1877 to 1902 changes were mixed, but mostly down; back of book saw no changes; Offices in Crete and Cavalle were up.

France - Reunion +0.1%

French Colonies no changes

French Congo -5.3%

French Equatorial Africa +34.3% Values for the World War II Liberation overprints skyrocketed, especially the semi-postal overprints; there were a large number of mixed value changes through 1955, although air mail and postage dues saw no changes.

French Guiana no changes

French India -0.4%

French Morocco +4.0% Many values changes both up and down.

French Polynesia -0.1%

French Southern and Antarctic Territories no change

French Sudan +3.2%

French West Africa -0.8%

Fujeira +1.6%

Funchal no changes


END OF VOLUME II

Overall value change for Volume II was +1.0%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

17 Aug 2016
05:55:17pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME III

Gabon -4.9% Changes were up to 1990 and were mostly down.

Gambia +8.4% Changes up to 1985 were mostly up; from 1985-1995 changes were all down; from 1995 onward changes were up.

Georgia -5.3% All changes were from 1993 onward and all were down.

German East Africa no changes

German New Guinea no changes

German South West Africa no changes

Germany -0.7% Only changes in German States was Baden and those were all down; Germany up to 1945, including semi-postals were mostly up; Belgian Occupation changes were mostly up; other occupation issues had few changes, and most of those were down; Berlin was mostly down; DDR had no changes; Offices in China were mostly down while offices in Turkey were mostly up.

Ghana -3.1% All changes up to 1972, and were mostly down.

Gibraltar +2.2% There were a large number of changes in this country. Up to 1995 changes were mostly down. From 2005-2011 changes mostly increases.

Gold Coast +9.3%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

26 Aug 2016
07:00:37pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Great Britain -3.5%

Issues from the Victoria to George V eras saw no changes. Issues From Edward VIII and George VI were down. No changes from that point until 2000 where a few stamps saw increases. No changes in Machins or regionals. Semi-Postals were down. Offices in Africa were mostly up.

Guernsey saw many changes with most being declines in the 20% to 30% range. Alderney was down. Jersey saw many changes up to 2010, all of which were declines in the 30% to 60% range. No changes after that. Postage dues were down, while occupation stamps were up. Isle of Man saw no changes.

Greece -2.3%

A nice change to the listings from 1986 on is that Scott now lists and values, with minor numbers, the booklet single stamps. Previously, Scott had a note stating that the booklet singles (they look like coils but are not, by the way) were worth about half of the regular stamps. That no longer holds true. Most of the booklet stamps are worth as much or more than the regular stamps.

Semi-postals are up. Postal Tax stamps saw several changes with most of them down. Occupations stamps mostly saw large decreases in the stamps with higher catalog values, while some other occupation stamps had increases. I do not have any stamps from Mount Athos.

Greenland -0.6%

All changes were decreases, and were before 1960.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

27 Aug 2016
10:49:14pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Grand Comoro / Comoro Islands -7.6% Grand Comoro saw no changes; changes in the Comoro Islands up to 1965 are all decreases. After that there are a few changes, most of which are decreases.

Grenada +4.1% All changes are increases up to 1950, with only a few more increases after that. The Grenadines saw no changes.

Griqualand West +212.5% That is no typo. Previous $40.00 valued stamps are now worth $125.00.

Guadeloupe no changes

Guatemala +1.5% From 1946-1948 and 1987 there are a few increases; Semi-postals are up; up to 1960 and from 1974 on air mail stamps increased; air post officials increased.

French Guinea / Guinea -2.9% Many changes in both areas, including back-of-book. Most of the changes were decreases.

Guyana -4.8% Many changes, with most being decreases. Be aware that many set totals from around 1989 and 1990 are incorrect (too low). I notified Scott about this error.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

02 Sep 2016
12:57:02pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Haiti +0.1% Very few and minor changes in air mail section.

Hatay -33.6%

Heligoland +5.2%

Honduras +0.1%

Hong Kong no changes

Horta no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

07 Sep 2016
12:35:54am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Hungary +1.1% Changes for postage and semi-postal stamps were all increases and found up to the early 1970s. Changes in air mail were almost all increases up to 1959.

Iceland had no changes

Ifni had no changes

India +0.7% The main country had no changes. Convention States had very few changes, all increases. The Native States of Travancore and Travancore-Cochin saw several changes both increases and decreases.

Indo-China had no changes

Indonesia +3.4% All changes were increases and before 1950 in postage, air mail, special delivery and official stamps. Riau Archipelago and West Irian had no changes.

Inhambane +1.3%

Inini had no changes

Ionian Islands had no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

10 Sep 2016
07:29:07pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Iran +13.0% All changes, mostly increases, were up to 1978. Officials also increased.

Iraq +1.6% All changes were between 1960 and 1964, and were all increases. Officials also increased.

Ireland +0.1% All changes were increases and were up to 1934.

Israel +0.1%

Italian Colonies -6.9%

Italian East Africa -7.1%

Italy -0.1%


Italian States: Roman States saw minor catalog number listings increase substantially; Sardinia and Tuscany increased.

Italy up to 1929 was mostly down, some substantially; back-of-book was generally down, but the following were almost all increases: special delivery; authorized delivery; postage due; occupation.

Italian offices saw many changes, most of which were increases.

Aegean Islands increased while Trieste Zone A saw no changes.

Ivory Coast -0.9% Almost all changes were in the colonial period, including air mail, and were decreases.


END OF VOLUME III

Overall value change for Volume III was +1.1%

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

11 Sep 2016
03:05:28pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME IV

Jamaica -0.4% Victoria and George V were mostly increases; George VI was mostly down; QEII was down; back-of-book was up.

Japan +0.2%

Jordan +10.2%
Up to 1960 value changes were mixed; back-of-book was mostly increases with some large.

Karelia -1.4%

Katanga -3.2%

Kazakhstan -10.7%

Kenya -5.4%
Up to 1980 changes were mostly decreases.

Kenya Uganda Tanzania +0.2% Up to QEII changes were mostly increases; QEII saw all decreases.

Kiauchau -7.8%

Kionga no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

12 Sep 2016
02:50:29am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Gilbert & Ellice Islands / Gilbert Island / Kiribati -2.8% Gilbert & Ellice Islands up to 1949 showed mostly increases; Gilbert Islands were mostly decreases; Kiribati up to 1990 was mostly down.

Korea -1.4% Up to 1960 changes were mostly down; air mails were down.

Korean Democratic People's Republic +0.3% No changes until the mid 2000s. They were all increases.

Kosovo -28.4%

Kuwait +3.4% Changes, which were all increases were up to 1961.

Kyrgyzstan no changes

Labuan +6.0%

Lagos +2.1%
All changes were increases and were in the Victoria era.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Sep 2016
01:51:57pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Laos +5.2% All changes were up to 1975 and were increases, including back-of-book.

Latakia no changes

Latvia no changes

Lebanon no changes

Leeward Islands +5.0% All changes were prior to 1935.

Lesotho -6.0% All changes were up to 1977 and were mostly decreases.

Liberia -11.9% Up to 1997 almost all changes were decreases, including air mail.

Libya -1.2% Italian colonial era was mostly down, except for air mail which was mostly up. Occupation stamps were mostly down.

Liechtenstein -4.4% Mostly increases up to 1995. After 1995 changes were mostly decreases.

Lithuania -3.9% Up to 1995 changes were mostly increases. From 1995 on changes were mostly down. Air mail was mostly down.

Lourenco Marques +2.0%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Sep 2016
11:09:44pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Luxembourg -0.9%

Macao +14.5% From 1948-1985 changes were mostly increases. From 1986-1995 changes were mostly decreases. From 1996 on changes were all increases. Postage dues saw mostly increases. Newspaper stamps increased. Many postal tax stamps saw huge increases.

Macedonia no changes

Madagascar (British) no stamps from this area

Malagasy Republic -2.3% Through 1941 changes were mostly decreases. From 1942-1960 changes were mostly increases, especially the France Libre overprints. From 1961-1981 changes were mixed. Air mail saw mostly decreases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

21 Sep 2016
03:03:24pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Malawi -1.6%

Malaya / Malaysia +9.6% Malaya saw mixed ups and downs. Malayan States were mostly up, and some stamps had somewhat large increases. Early Malaysia saw decreases. Malaysian States saw no changes.

Maldive Islands +6.4% All of this came on a few modern souvenir sheets.

Mali no changes

Malta -0.2% Victoria listings saw no changes. Edward and George V listing increased. George VI saw a mix of increases and decreases Elizabeth II up to 2010 was mostly decreases. Semi-postal and air mail were down. Early postage dies increases while the newer ones decreased.

Manchukuo +33.7% Scott revalued almost all of the stamps from this area. There are no more minimum-valued stamps. The lowest value for a stamp here is now 50 cents. Value increases for many stamps commonly ranged from 100% to 200%. There were a few decreases, but everything else was up.

Mariana Islands no changes

Marienwerder no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

24 Sep 2016
02:29:44am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Marshall Islands no change

Martinique no change

Mauritania -0.3% Colonial era was mostly down; air mail and postage dues were mostly down.

Mauritius +3.4% Victoria era was up; Edward was down as was George V.

Mayotte no change

Memel -2.8% There were many changes with most of them down, especially occupation stamps.

Mesopotamia +2.9%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 Oct 2016
12:09:15pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Mexico no change

Micronesia no change

Middle Congo / Congo People's Republic -1.3% Middle Congo changes were almost all down. Congo People's Republic changes through 1976 were almost all increases. The early 1990s were mostly decreases, however.

Moheli no change

Moldova -2.6%

Monaco -7.6%
Value changes were found throughout the entire listings through air mail and were mostly decreases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Oct 2016
09:55:10am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Mongolia +0.4%

Montenegro no change

Montserrat no change

Morocco +14.8%

Mozambique +1.3%
Scattered changes, all increases, up through 1963.

Mozambique Company +7.4%


END OF VOLUME IV

Overall value change for Volume IV was +1.7%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Oct 2016
10:22:03am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME V

Natal +1.2%

Nauru -4.8%

Nepal +57.9% All changes were increases. This was a complete review and update of the country by Scott.

Netherlands +0.8%

Netherlands Antilles no changes

Netherlands Indies no changes

Netherlands New Guinea +3.2% All changes were in semi-postals.

Nevis +0.3% All changes wee in the Victorian era.

New Britain no changes

New Caledonia no changes

New Guinea +0.9%

New Hebrides (French Issues) +3.8%

New Republic no stamps

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

23 Oct 2016
11:25:29am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

New Zealand -0.5% Ross Dependency had no change.

Nicaragua -7.7% Many changes, but the big hit came with a huge decrease in the 1994 Alien Sightings issue.

Niger -3.4% Only changes were decreases in the French colonial era, and air mail that were also mostly down.

Niger Coast Protectorate +9.6%

Nigeria +12.9%
Values prior to George VI were increases, GVI were mostly down, QEII were mostly up, post independence was mostly up.

Niue +0.6%

Norfolk Island +0.6%

North Borneo +2.8%

Northern Nigeria +20.4%

Northern Rhodesia +5.1%

North Ingermanland +4.4%


North West Pacific Islands no changes

Norway no changes

Nossi-Be no changes

Nyasaland Protectorate +5.8%

Nyassa +2.1%

Obock +1.3%

Oltre Giuba +14.0%

Oman -9.2% All changes were in the British era.

Orange River Colony +1.0%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Nov 2016
12:18:48am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Pakistan -3.9% Up to 1956 values were mostly down. From 1957 to around 2000 almost all values were down with many large decreases. From 2000 onward, values were up. Bahawalpur was down.

Palau no changes

Palestine +0.3%

Palestinian Authority -0.4% Many value changes all prior to 2000.

Panama +0.1%

Papua New Guinea +1.0%
All changes were up through 1934.

Paraguay +0.1% Many value changes, mostly down, in the postage section from 1940 onward and in the air mail section from 1950 onward.

Penrhyn Island +0.1%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

14 Nov 2016
06:00:10pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Peru -0.8% All changes, mostly declines, were from 1978 to 1985.

Philippines -0.1%

Pitcairn Islands -16.6%
Major value decreases up to 2010. There were some increases from 2010 t 2011, and then no changes after that.

Poland +0.4% Only changes were in occupation stamps and Offices in Danzig.

Ponta Delgada no changes

Portugal +0.3%

Azores +2.1%
Almost all changes were prior to 1980.

Madeira no changes

Portuguese Africa +4.3% All changes were in back-of-book stamps.

Portuguese Congo +3.1%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

19 Nov 2016
11:18:32am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Portuguese Guinea / Guinea Bissau +1.1% The only changes were in postal tax stamps.

Portuguese India +1.3%

Puerto Rico -1.0%

Qatar +1.7% All changes occurred before 1966.

Quelimane +11.2%

Ras Al Khaima - I do not have any of the Scott listed stamps.

Rio De Oro no changes

Rio Muni no changes

Romania +0.1% There were many changes scattered through the listings. Changes in the postage stamps were mostly down. Semi-postal, air mail, air mail semi-postal stamps and offices in the Turkish Empire saw mostly increases. Several postage dues were up sharply. The increases in back-of-the-book eliminated the overall decreases in the postage section.

Rouad no changes

Ruanda-Urundi no changes


Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

22 Nov 2016
09:42:27pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Russia +5.2% Almost all value changes were before 1960, and were mostly increases. Changes in semi-postals and postage dues were increases. Offices in Turkey were down.

Rwanda no changes

Saar no changes

St. Christopher - St. Kitts +0.6% All changes were in the St. Christopher listings.

St. Helena +1.2% All changes were prior to George VI.

St. Kitts-Nevis +0.6% Almost all changes were prior to 1930, and in the war tax stamps.

St. Lucia +2.5% All changes were in the Victoria era.

Ste. Marie de Madagascar no changes

St. Martin no stamps from this area

St. Pierre & Miquelon no changes

St. Thomas & Prince Islands +0.2% All changes were in the 19th Century listings.

St. Vincent - St. Vincent and the Grenadines +0.5% No changes in St. Vincent. St. Vincent Grenadines were mostly down while the local islands were up.

Salvador -0.8% The first set was up. Values from 1970-1990 were mostly down as was air mail.

Samoa +0.2% Only changes were in the 1935 definitive set.

END OF VOLUME V

Overall value change for Volume V was +1.0%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

24 Nov 2016
12:07:00pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME VI

San Marino -3.0% All changes were decreases and were from 1932 through 1947.

Sarawak +6.3% All changes were up to 1964 and were mostly increases.

Saseno no changes

Saudi Arabia +0.9%

Schleswig +1.0%


Senegal -5.8% Most changes were in the colonial era, and were mostly decreases.

Senegambia & Niger -14.3%

Serbia +0.4% All changes were prior to 1903.

Seychelles +6.9% All changes were prior to QEII era and were all increases. Zil Elwannyen Sesel had no changes.

Shanghai no changes

Sharjah & Dependencies no changes

Siberia no changes

Sierra Leone +6.3% All changes, mostly increases, were prior to 1946.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

27 Nov 2016
03:49:10pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Singapore -5.0% Many value changes, mostly down.

Slovakia -0.1%

Slovenia -0.2%

Solomon Islands +3.8% Most changes were before 1961.

Somalia -0.3% Most changes were before 1935.

Somali Coast / Afars and Issas / Djibuti -3.8% Somali Coast had many changes, mostly down. Afars and Issas was down. Djibuti increased.

Somaliland Protectorate +7.4%

South Africa +4.1% Changes were prior to 1950, especially definitive pairs. There were no changes in the back-of-book or the homelands.

South Arabia -5.3%

Southern Nigeria no changes

Southern Rhodesia +1.4%

South Georgia -9.8% Decreases were in the first definitive set.

South Russia -22.5%

South Sudan no stamps

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

28 Dec 2016
11:55:44am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

South West Africa / Namibia +1.5% South West Africa saw mixed changes that were mostly increases. Namibia had mixed changes that were mostly decreases.

Spain +1.1% Very few changes.

Spanish Guinea no changes

Spanish Morocco no changes

Spanish Sahara no changes

Spanish West Africa no changes

Ceylon / Sri Lanka +1.3% Ceylon had mostly increases up to 1910. Sri Lanka had very few changes, most of which were increases.

Stellaland no stamps from this area

Straits Settlements -0.1% All changes were in the 19th Century.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Jan 2017
01:47:31am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Sudan +1.0% All changes were prior to 1935.

Surinam no changes

Swaziland +1.1%

Sweden -2.6% Prior to 1910 all changes were decreases. Some booklets prior to 1970 saw increases. Officials were down.

Switzerland no changes

Syria / Syrian Arab Government / United Arab Republic issues for Syria no changes

Tahiti no changes

Tajikistan no changes

Tanganyika +10.1% All changes, mostly increases, were prior to 1961.

Tannu Tuva -2.7% Air mail values decreased.

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

07 Jan 2017
11:50:31am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Tanzania +0.8%

Tete +27.2%


Thailand no changes

Thrace -0.6%

Tibet no changes

Timor +8.9%

Tobago +4.7%


Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

11 Jan 2017
11:09:02am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Togo -3.2% German era was down; British era had no changes; French era and the Republic era were mixed.

Tokelau -10.9% All changes were prior to 1971 and were down.

Tonga and Niuafo'ou had no changes

Transcaucasion Federated Republic no changes

Transvaal no changes

Trinidad +8.8%

Trinidad and Tobago +2.7%
King George V and VI were mostly up. QEII issues saw many changes, especially the definitive sets, with commemorative sets mostly down and the definitives mixed.

Tripolitania -1.8%

Tristan da Cunha -6.9%
Changes in the QEII era was mostly all down.

Trucial States -0.5%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

13 Jan 2017
12:40:31am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Tunisia -7.0% Many changes, mostly down, up to the mid 1970s. After that, changes were mostly up, but there were not many of them.

Turkey +0.4% Only a small number of changes scattered throughout all the listings.

Turkey in Asia no changes

Turkish Cyprus +0.8% There were only a small number of changes, mostly increases.

Turkmenistan no changes

Turks and Caicos Islands +0.4% All changes were in the Victoria era.
Caicos Islands had no changes.

Turks Islands no changes

Tuvalu -0.5% No changes in the main listings, but islands were down slightly.

Ubangi-Shari -15.8% There were many changes, mostly all were decreases.

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

15 Jan 2017
12:40:53am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Uganda +1.4% All changes, all increases, were in the Victoria era.

Ukraine no changes

Umm Al Qiwain no changes

United Arab Emirates no changes

Upper Senegal & Niger -17.0% There were large decreases in the first definitive set, and some small increases in the second.

Upper Silesia no changes

Uruguay -1.9% Changes from 1948-1962 were few, but were all increases. From 1963-1999 changes were mostly decreases, with many increases from the mid 1980s on. From 2000 on there were many large increases. Air Mails were mostly down. Many value changes, both increases and decreases, were 40% and more.

Uzbekistan no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

16 Jan 2017
10:13:07am
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

New Hebrides (British) - Vanuatu +0.1% Vanuatu was unchanged.

Vatican City no changes

Venezuela -0.1%

Viet Nam -0.3%


Virgin Islands +1.6% All changes were in the Victoria era.

Wallis and Futuna Islands no changes

Western Ukraine no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

16 Jan 2017
09:18:19pm
re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Yemen no changes

Yemen People's Democratic Republic no changes

Yugoslavia +0.4% Value changes were all increases and were from 1937 through 1948 with a few changes in air mails. All other areas under Yugoslavia, including Trieste, locals, occupations, etc. had no changes.

Belgian Congo - Congo Democratic Republic - Zaire -4.0% All changes, mostly decreases, were in the Belgian Congo.

Zambezia +2.1%

Zambia -10.0%

Zanzibar -0.7%
Changes in the 19th Century were all increases. Changes from 1900 through 1936 were mostly decreases.

Rhodesia - Rhodesia & Nyasaland - Rhodesia State - Zimbabwe -0.9% Changes in the 19th Century were all increases. Changes in Rhodesia & Nyasaland were mostly decreases. Rhodesia State and Zimbabwe had no changes.

Zululand +3.2%


END OF VOLUME VI

Overall value change for Volume VI was +0.2%

END OF CATALOG REVIEW

Overall value change from 2015 catalogs to 2017 catalogs was +1.9%

Like
Login to Like
this post
        

 

Author/Postings
michael78651

09 May 2016
01:22:31am

This thread contains my review of a catalog value comparison between the 2015 Scott catalogs and the 2017 Scott Catalogs. It is strictly a comparison of values of the stamps in my personal collection. If you were to do the same thing as what I am doing here, your results may be different if your collection is made up differently than mine. An example would be that most of my Czechoslovakia is primarily mint, never hinged and almost complete. If you collect Czechoslovakia, but it is primarily used incomplete sets and only 35% complete, you may see different results if you did this review.

As I list the various countries, in Scott order unless specified otherwise, I will add some comments of possible interest to let you know what I have found. If the comparison of a country doesn't offer much, then there will not be much if any special notes.

There is one rule with this thread, do NOT post comments on this thread. Comments will make it difficult for others to see the reviews as I post them. Any comments posted here will be deleted. You've been warned, so don't complain if you post and it is deleted.

You are welcome to post all the comments you want on the catalog review post thread.

Thanks for everyone's cooperation, and enjoy the reviews.

Like 
5 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

09 May 2016
01:31:59am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

SCOTT CATALOG VOLUME I

United States +0.3%

Stamps from 1922-1925 saw a decrease in never hinged values. From 1980 onward values for booklets, booklet panes and booklet singles are generally down. Definitive stamps from 2000 and 2001 increased in value. The imperf Bugs Bunny sheet saw a nice increase. A large number of stamps issued from 2008-2013 saw increases. The high value Priority and Express mail stamps saw nice increases. All but the last semi-postal stamp increased in value. A few early air mails saw changes, mostly upwards. Confederate States saw no change.

United States: Canal Zone -0.8%

Most of the changes were found in the pre-USA issues. The first USA issue saw increases.

United States: Guam (no change)

United States: Hawaii +4.3%

The only changes, and they were almost all upwards were found in the provisional government overprint issues of 1893.

United States: Ryukyu Islands -5.3%

Values changes, almost all downward, were contained in the stamps issued through 1966. This includes the air mails.

Like 
6 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

09 May 2016
03:34:33pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

United Nations -0.7%

New York: Higher valued sets issued prior to 1988 were down. After 1988 there was not much activity. A few higher valued stamps were either up or down.

Geneva: 1999 Australia souvenir booklet was up. No other changes.

Vienna: 1999 Australia souvenir booklet was up as was the 2006 Indigenous Art sheet.

Abu Dhabi -0.5%

Most of the loss was in the first definitive set.

Aden and States -10.7%

King George VI era stamps were down considerably. Queen Elizabeth II era stamps were generally up, but not enough to offset the losses from her father.

Afghanistan +1.7%

Only changes were in the stamps issued from 1928-1932, and these were almost all increases.

Aguerra, La (no changes)

Aitutaki -0.5%

All changes were in the stamps issued in the 1920s.

Ajman +13.0%

All stamps in MNH condition increased in value.

Alaouites +10.5%

Stamps in the first definitive set increased as did the black overprinted postage due stamps from 1925.

Like 
4 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 May 2016
11:16:41pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Albania -16.5%

Up to 1922 and then after 1946 values were down 20 to 50% or more on many stamps. After 1946 there were some increases, but not nearly enough to overcome the declines.

Alexandretta +13.5%

The air mail set is the only change.

Algeria -0.4%

A wild ride with ups and downs all over the place through 1979, including semi-postal and postage dues. From 1980 onward, especially the 2000s the changes were mostly increases, but not enough to balance the ledger.

Allenstein +5.5%

All changes were with used stamps.

Andorra (Spanish and French) no changes

Angola +1.9%

Angra (no changes)

Anguilla -6.6%

All value changes were up to 2002.

Anjouan no changes

Annam & Tonkin no changes

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

16 May 2016
11:52:38am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Antigua +0.3%

Up to 1930 values are up. After 1930, values are down.

Argentina +0.0%

Many value changes from 1951 on, including semi-postals. All evened out in the end.

Armenia (no change)

Aruba -21.7%

I don't have many stamps from here. What I do have took a deep sea dive, and didn't find any pearls.

Ascension +5.5%

George V increased; George VI increased alot; QEII saw increases and decreases from 1976 on.

Australia -1.0%

Victoria and Western Australia saw no changes. The other states saw some increases and decreases. Australia up to 1930 saw increases. Australian Antarctic Territory pre 2000 decreased, and after 2000 increased.

Austria -0.4%

Little change in the country listings. Offices in Crete saw increases and decreases.

Azerbaijan +0.9%

All changes were in the first set.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 May 2016
10:03:02am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Bahamas +0.3%

Bahrain +2.0%

All changes were before 1953.

Bangkok - no stamps

Bangladesh - no changes

Barbados +2.6%

pre-QEII were increases; QEII were up and down with all up from the 1990s onward.

Barbuda -1.1%

Basutoland -1.0%

Batum +62.7%

Not a typo. Just about everything increased.

Bechuanaland +46.2%

Also not a typo. Many increases prior to QEII, then mixed with mostly increases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

29 May 2016
04:25:19pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Belarus +9.5%

Belgium -0.3%

Increases through the World War II era. Afterwards up to 2005 mostly decreases with many on the large side that wiped out the increases in the older stamps. No change in back-of-book.

Benin (French Colony) -4.8%

Bermuda +1.2%

All changes were prior to 1935.

Bhutan -1.5%

All changes were prior to 1973, including air mails.

Biafra -2.9%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

04 Jun 2016
11:27:47pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Bolivia -12.1%

Value changes from 1946 on show decreases of 50% or more. Includes postage and air mails.

Bosnia & Herzegovina (no change)

Botswana -5.6%

Changes were with the first two definitive sets.

Brazil -0.4%

Almost all changes were up to 1890 and were mostly down.

British Antarctic Territory -5.8%

While other sets saw decreases, the major drop was with the first definitive set.

British Central Africa +2.3%

British East Africa +3.7%

British Guiana +1.5%


Changes were up through 1937.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 Jun 2016
11:59:51am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

British Honduras / Belize +3.1%

Almost all changes were in the Queen Victoria era. A few changes afterwards, including in Belize.

British Indian Ocean Territory +3.0%

First two definitive sets saw increases. After that changes were mostly down.

Brunei +2.1%

All changes were prior to 1949.

Bulgaria +1.0%

All changes were prior to 1953.

Burkina Faso +0.7%

All changes were prior to 1929. Postage dues saw changes as well.

Burma +9.7%

Mixed changes, but many more increases than decreases. The changes covered the British era and afterwards, officials and Japanese occupation.

Burundi -1.7%

Bushire: no stamps from this area.


END OF VOLUME I

Overall total value change for Volume I (not including USA or UN) was -0.2%

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Jun 2016
10:54:23pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

SCOTT CATALOG VOLUME II

Cambodia -0.9%

Cameroun - Cameroons +1.4%

German era was down, British Cameroons was up, French era was mixed.

Canada -0.6%

Provinces were mostly up with some very large increases. Canada was mixed up to 1950 with mostly a downward. From 1977 to 2009 values are down. From 2010 values are mixed. Back of book is mixed.

Cape Juby had no changes

Cape of Good Hope +19.0%

Cape Verde +1.2%

Very small number of changes. See 1886 definitive set and 1962 sports set. Other than that only a couple of other changes.

Caribbean Netherlands no stamps from this area

Caroline Islands had no changes

Castellorizo -16.7%

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

24 Jun 2016
07:58:23pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Cayman Islands +0.1%

All changes were in the Victoria era.

Central African Republic - no changes

Central Lithuania - no changes

Chad +6.9%

Up to 1970 changes were mixed; from around 1995-1999 values were up; semi-postals were up as were air mail (up to 1972), air mail semi-postal and postage dues.

Chile +9.5%

Increases up to 1950 with a few more later on, but not many; air mail and postal tax stamps also increased.

China -8.8%

Large decreases through 1894. No changes in back-of-book, provinces and occupations.

China - People's Republic -8.6%

Up to 1983 changes were mixed with large decreases and some modest increases; Liberation Areas saw no changes.

Christmas Island -6.4%

Up to 1986 almost everything decreased. Those that did not go down had no changes. From 1987 to around 2009, values were mixed; from 2010 onward, values were up, some changes were large, especially for minor catalog numbers. (Remember that my son did this area for 2016-2017 catalog values and saw a 5.5% decrease.)

Cilicia +0.1%

Cochin China - no stamps

Cocos Islands -6.7%

Up to 1986 values were mostly down, especially with the earliest issues and definitive sets, with a few small increases. After that, there were no changes.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

02 Jul 2016
05:26:20pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Colombia +1.3%

All changes were increases and were found in the 1959 to 1970 air mails.

Cook Islands +0.5%

Corfu -15.3%

Costa Rica +0.9%

All changes were increases and were found in the postage and air mail areas for 1990-2002, and postal tax from 1985 onward.

Crete -4.9%

Many changes, both up and down.

Croatia -6.6%

Up to 1994 value changes were mixed; 1943 semi-postals were down; postal tax from 1993-1997 was up.

Cuba +6.0%

All changes, which were mixed, were found in the 19th Century.

Curacao - No stamps from this area.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

15 Jul 2016
05:16:41pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Cyprus +0.7%

Cyrenaica +6.9%

Czechoslovakia +0.9%

Most changes were prior to 1970. Bohemia & Moravia had no changes.

Dahomey / Benin People's Republic -6.1%

Changes in Dahomey were mostly up prior to World War II. Benin PR was mostly up prior to 1980, and then from 1996 onward was down.

- Dalmatia had no changes

Danish West Indies -1.3%

Danzig +1.5%

Denmark +1.5%

Don't let that little percentage increase fool you. There were tons of changes, up and down, large and small throughout the entire listings. Back-of-book material saw some large increases, and I think that is where in the end the net was an overall increase. Without that, I think Denmark would have been down about 2 percentage points.

Diego Suarez -2.0%


Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

23 Jul 2016
12:57:01am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Dominica +3.3% Increases up to 1940; 1940-1970 mixed changes; 1970-1990 values were down; after 1990 no changes.

Dominican Republic -0.1%

Dubai +7.1%

East Africa and Uganda Protectorates +0.9%

Eastern Rumelia no changes

Eastern Silesia no changes

Ecuador -3.1% Changes from 1946-1995, including air mail, were mostly down.

Egypt +0.1%

Elobey, Annobon and Corisco no changes

Epirus +1.8%

Equatorial Guinea no changes

Eritrea +2.5% All changes were in the Italian colonial period.

Estonia no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Aug 2016
07:35:51pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Ethiopia no changes

Falkland Islands +0.4% Victoria through George V saw increases; George VI was mostly increases; QEII was mostly decreases. The dependencies were mostly down.

Far Eastern Republic +5.9%

Faroe Islands no changes

Fernando Po +6.5%

Fiji -0.3% all changes were prior to George VI; postage dues were down

Finland +1.8% While the net overall change is small, the number of changes in this country were vast, and covered all areas. Up to 1950 saw mostly increases with many of them 50% or higher; the 1950s were mixed; from 1960 onward saw mostly decreases many on the large side of 30% to 50%. The Aland Islands saw increases, some large, up to 1993. After that, values were mostly down.

Fiume no changes

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Aug 2016
11:32:42am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

France -2.5% Changes up to 1876 were down; from 1877 to 1902 changes were mixed, but mostly down; back of book saw no changes; Offices in Crete and Cavalle were up.

France - Reunion +0.1%

French Colonies no changes

French Congo -5.3%

French Equatorial Africa +34.3% Values for the World War II Liberation overprints skyrocketed, especially the semi-postal overprints; there were a large number of mixed value changes through 1955, although air mail and postage dues saw no changes.

French Guiana no changes

French India -0.4%

French Morocco +4.0% Many values changes both up and down.

French Polynesia -0.1%

French Southern and Antarctic Territories no change

French Sudan +3.2%

French West Africa -0.8%

Fujeira +1.6%

Funchal no changes


END OF VOLUME II

Overall value change for Volume II was +1.0%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

17 Aug 2016
05:55:17pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME III

Gabon -4.9% Changes were up to 1990 and were mostly down.

Gambia +8.4% Changes up to 1985 were mostly up; from 1985-1995 changes were all down; from 1995 onward changes were up.

Georgia -5.3% All changes were from 1993 onward and all were down.

German East Africa no changes

German New Guinea no changes

German South West Africa no changes

Germany -0.7% Only changes in German States was Baden and those were all down; Germany up to 1945, including semi-postals were mostly up; Belgian Occupation changes were mostly up; other occupation issues had few changes, and most of those were down; Berlin was mostly down; DDR had no changes; Offices in China were mostly down while offices in Turkey were mostly up.

Ghana -3.1% All changes up to 1972, and were mostly down.

Gibraltar +2.2% There were a large number of changes in this country. Up to 1995 changes were mostly down. From 2005-2011 changes mostly increases.

Gold Coast +9.3%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

26 Aug 2016
07:00:37pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Great Britain -3.5%

Issues from the Victoria to George V eras saw no changes. Issues From Edward VIII and George VI were down. No changes from that point until 2000 where a few stamps saw increases. No changes in Machins or regionals. Semi-Postals were down. Offices in Africa were mostly up.

Guernsey saw many changes with most being declines in the 20% to 30% range. Alderney was down. Jersey saw many changes up to 2010, all of which were declines in the 30% to 60% range. No changes after that. Postage dues were down, while occupation stamps were up. Isle of Man saw no changes.

Greece -2.3%

A nice change to the listings from 1986 on is that Scott now lists and values, with minor numbers, the booklet single stamps. Previously, Scott had a note stating that the booklet singles (they look like coils but are not, by the way) were worth about half of the regular stamps. That no longer holds true. Most of the booklet stamps are worth as much or more than the regular stamps.

Semi-postals are up. Postal Tax stamps saw several changes with most of them down. Occupations stamps mostly saw large decreases in the stamps with higher catalog values, while some other occupation stamps had increases. I do not have any stamps from Mount Athos.

Greenland -0.6%

All changes were decreases, and were before 1960.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

27 Aug 2016
10:49:14pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Grand Comoro / Comoro Islands -7.6% Grand Comoro saw no changes; changes in the Comoro Islands up to 1965 are all decreases. After that there are a few changes, most of which are decreases.

Grenada +4.1% All changes are increases up to 1950, with only a few more increases after that. The Grenadines saw no changes.

Griqualand West +212.5% That is no typo. Previous $40.00 valued stamps are now worth $125.00.

Guadeloupe no changes

Guatemala +1.5% From 1946-1948 and 1987 there are a few increases; Semi-postals are up; up to 1960 and from 1974 on air mail stamps increased; air post officials increased.

French Guinea / Guinea -2.9% Many changes in both areas, including back-of-book. Most of the changes were decreases.

Guyana -4.8% Many changes, with most being decreases. Be aware that many set totals from around 1989 and 1990 are incorrect (too low). I notified Scott about this error.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

02 Sep 2016
12:57:02pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Haiti +0.1% Very few and minor changes in air mail section.

Hatay -33.6%

Heligoland +5.2%

Honduras +0.1%

Hong Kong no changes

Horta no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

07 Sep 2016
12:35:54am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Hungary +1.1% Changes for postage and semi-postal stamps were all increases and found up to the early 1970s. Changes in air mail were almost all increases up to 1959.

Iceland had no changes

Ifni had no changes

India +0.7% The main country had no changes. Convention States had very few changes, all increases. The Native States of Travancore and Travancore-Cochin saw several changes both increases and decreases.

Indo-China had no changes

Indonesia +3.4% All changes were increases and before 1950 in postage, air mail, special delivery and official stamps. Riau Archipelago and West Irian had no changes.

Inhambane +1.3%

Inini had no changes

Ionian Islands had no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

10 Sep 2016
07:29:07pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Iran +13.0% All changes, mostly increases, were up to 1978. Officials also increased.

Iraq +1.6% All changes were between 1960 and 1964, and were all increases. Officials also increased.

Ireland +0.1% All changes were increases and were up to 1934.

Israel +0.1%

Italian Colonies -6.9%

Italian East Africa -7.1%

Italy -0.1%


Italian States: Roman States saw minor catalog number listings increase substantially; Sardinia and Tuscany increased.

Italy up to 1929 was mostly down, some substantially; back-of-book was generally down, but the following were almost all increases: special delivery; authorized delivery; postage due; occupation.

Italian offices saw many changes, most of which were increases.

Aegean Islands increased while Trieste Zone A saw no changes.

Ivory Coast -0.9% Almost all changes were in the colonial period, including air mail, and were decreases.


END OF VOLUME III

Overall value change for Volume III was +1.1%

Like 
3 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

11 Sep 2016
03:05:28pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME IV

Jamaica -0.4% Victoria and George V were mostly increases; George VI was mostly down; QEII was down; back-of-book was up.

Japan +0.2%

Jordan +10.2%
Up to 1960 value changes were mixed; back-of-book was mostly increases with some large.

Karelia -1.4%

Katanga -3.2%

Kazakhstan -10.7%

Kenya -5.4%
Up to 1980 changes were mostly decreases.

Kenya Uganda Tanzania +0.2% Up to QEII changes were mostly increases; QEII saw all decreases.

Kiauchau -7.8%

Kionga no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

12 Sep 2016
02:50:29am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Gilbert & Ellice Islands / Gilbert Island / Kiribati -2.8% Gilbert & Ellice Islands up to 1949 showed mostly increases; Gilbert Islands were mostly decreases; Kiribati up to 1990 was mostly down.

Korea -1.4% Up to 1960 changes were mostly down; air mails were down.

Korean Democratic People's Republic +0.3% No changes until the mid 2000s. They were all increases.

Kosovo -28.4%

Kuwait +3.4% Changes, which were all increases were up to 1961.

Kyrgyzstan no changes

Labuan +6.0%

Lagos +2.1%
All changes were increases and were in the Victoria era.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Sep 2016
01:51:57pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Laos +5.2% All changes were up to 1975 and were increases, including back-of-book.

Latakia no changes

Latvia no changes

Lebanon no changes

Leeward Islands +5.0% All changes were prior to 1935.

Lesotho -6.0% All changes were up to 1977 and were mostly decreases.

Liberia -11.9% Up to 1997 almost all changes were decreases, including air mail.

Libya -1.2% Italian colonial era was mostly down, except for air mail which was mostly up. Occupation stamps were mostly down.

Liechtenstein -4.4% Mostly increases up to 1995. After 1995 changes were mostly decreases.

Lithuania -3.9% Up to 1995 changes were mostly increases. From 1995 on changes were mostly down. Air mail was mostly down.

Lourenco Marques +2.0%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Sep 2016
11:09:44pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Luxembourg -0.9%

Macao +14.5% From 1948-1985 changes were mostly increases. From 1986-1995 changes were mostly decreases. From 1996 on changes were all increases. Postage dues saw mostly increases. Newspaper stamps increased. Many postal tax stamps saw huge increases.

Macedonia no changes

Madagascar (British) no stamps from this area

Malagasy Republic -2.3% Through 1941 changes were mostly decreases. From 1942-1960 changes were mostly increases, especially the France Libre overprints. From 1961-1981 changes were mixed. Air mail saw mostly decreases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

21 Sep 2016
03:03:24pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Malawi -1.6%

Malaya / Malaysia +9.6% Malaya saw mixed ups and downs. Malayan States were mostly up, and some stamps had somewhat large increases. Early Malaysia saw decreases. Malaysian States saw no changes.

Maldive Islands +6.4% All of this came on a few modern souvenir sheets.

Mali no changes

Malta -0.2% Victoria listings saw no changes. Edward and George V listing increased. George VI saw a mix of increases and decreases Elizabeth II up to 2010 was mostly decreases. Semi-postal and air mail were down. Early postage dies increases while the newer ones decreased.

Manchukuo +33.7% Scott revalued almost all of the stamps from this area. There are no more minimum-valued stamps. The lowest value for a stamp here is now 50 cents. Value increases for many stamps commonly ranged from 100% to 200%. There were a few decreases, but everything else was up.

Mariana Islands no changes

Marienwerder no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

24 Sep 2016
02:29:44am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Marshall Islands no change

Martinique no change

Mauritania -0.3% Colonial era was mostly down; air mail and postage dues were mostly down.

Mauritius +3.4% Victoria era was up; Edward was down as was George V.

Mayotte no change

Memel -2.8% There were many changes with most of them down, especially occupation stamps.

Mesopotamia +2.9%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

10 Oct 2016
12:09:15pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Mexico no change

Micronesia no change

Middle Congo / Congo People's Republic -1.3% Middle Congo changes were almost all down. Congo People's Republic changes through 1976 were almost all increases. The early 1990s were mostly decreases, however.

Moheli no change

Moldova -2.6%

Monaco -7.6%
Value changes were found throughout the entire listings through air mail and were mostly decreases.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

12 Oct 2016
09:55:10am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Mongolia +0.4%

Montenegro no change

Montserrat no change

Morocco +14.8%

Mozambique +1.3%
Scattered changes, all increases, up through 1963.

Mozambique Company +7.4%


END OF VOLUME IV

Overall value change for Volume IV was +1.7%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

18 Oct 2016
10:22:03am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME V

Natal +1.2%

Nauru -4.8%

Nepal +57.9% All changes were increases. This was a complete review and update of the country by Scott.

Netherlands +0.8%

Netherlands Antilles no changes

Netherlands Indies no changes

Netherlands New Guinea +3.2% All changes were in semi-postals.

Nevis +0.3% All changes wee in the Victorian era.

New Britain no changes

New Caledonia no changes

New Guinea +0.9%

New Hebrides (French Issues) +3.8%

New Republic no stamps

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

23 Oct 2016
11:25:29am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

New Zealand -0.5% Ross Dependency had no change.

Nicaragua -7.7% Many changes, but the big hit came with a huge decrease in the 1994 Alien Sightings issue.

Niger -3.4% Only changes were decreases in the French colonial era, and air mail that were also mostly down.

Niger Coast Protectorate +9.6%

Nigeria +12.9%
Values prior to George VI were increases, GVI were mostly down, QEII were mostly up, post independence was mostly up.

Niue +0.6%

Norfolk Island +0.6%

North Borneo +2.8%

Northern Nigeria +20.4%

Northern Rhodesia +5.1%

North Ingermanland +4.4%


North West Pacific Islands no changes

Norway no changes

Nossi-Be no changes

Nyasaland Protectorate +5.8%

Nyassa +2.1%

Obock +1.3%

Oltre Giuba +14.0%

Oman -9.2% All changes were in the British era.

Orange River Colony +1.0%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Nov 2016
12:18:48am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Pakistan -3.9% Up to 1956 values were mostly down. From 1957 to around 2000 almost all values were down with many large decreases. From 2000 onward, values were up. Bahawalpur was down.

Palau no changes

Palestine +0.3%

Palestinian Authority -0.4% Many value changes all prior to 2000.

Panama +0.1%

Papua New Guinea +1.0%
All changes were up through 1934.

Paraguay +0.1% Many value changes, mostly down, in the postage section from 1940 onward and in the air mail section from 1950 onward.

Penrhyn Island +0.1%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

14 Nov 2016
06:00:10pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Peru -0.8% All changes, mostly declines, were from 1978 to 1985.

Philippines -0.1%

Pitcairn Islands -16.6%
Major value decreases up to 2010. There were some increases from 2010 t 2011, and then no changes after that.

Poland +0.4% Only changes were in occupation stamps and Offices in Danzig.

Ponta Delgada no changes

Portugal +0.3%

Azores +2.1%
Almost all changes were prior to 1980.

Madeira no changes

Portuguese Africa +4.3% All changes were in back-of-book stamps.

Portuguese Congo +3.1%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

19 Nov 2016
11:18:32am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Portuguese Guinea / Guinea Bissau +1.1% The only changes were in postal tax stamps.

Portuguese India +1.3%

Puerto Rico -1.0%

Qatar +1.7% All changes occurred before 1966.

Quelimane +11.2%

Ras Al Khaima - I do not have any of the Scott listed stamps.

Rio De Oro no changes

Rio Muni no changes

Romania +0.1% There were many changes scattered through the listings. Changes in the postage stamps were mostly down. Semi-postal, air mail, air mail semi-postal stamps and offices in the Turkish Empire saw mostly increases. Several postage dues were up sharply. The increases in back-of-the-book eliminated the overall decreases in the postage section.

Rouad no changes

Ruanda-Urundi no changes


Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

22 Nov 2016
09:42:27pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Russia +5.2% Almost all value changes were before 1960, and were mostly increases. Changes in semi-postals and postage dues were increases. Offices in Turkey were down.

Rwanda no changes

Saar no changes

St. Christopher - St. Kitts +0.6% All changes were in the St. Christopher listings.

St. Helena +1.2% All changes were prior to George VI.

St. Kitts-Nevis +0.6% Almost all changes were prior to 1930, and in the war tax stamps.

St. Lucia +2.5% All changes were in the Victoria era.

Ste. Marie de Madagascar no changes

St. Martin no stamps from this area

St. Pierre & Miquelon no changes

St. Thomas & Prince Islands +0.2% All changes were in the 19th Century listings.

St. Vincent - St. Vincent and the Grenadines +0.5% No changes in St. Vincent. St. Vincent Grenadines were mostly down while the local islands were up.

Salvador -0.8% The first set was up. Values from 1970-1990 were mostly down as was air mail.

Samoa +0.2% Only changes were in the 1935 definitive set.

END OF VOLUME V

Overall value change for Volume V was +1.0%

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

24 Nov 2016
12:07:00pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

START OF VOLUME VI

San Marino -3.0% All changes were decreases and were from 1932 through 1947.

Sarawak +6.3% All changes were up to 1964 and were mostly increases.

Saseno no changes

Saudi Arabia +0.9%

Schleswig +1.0%


Senegal -5.8% Most changes were in the colonial era, and were mostly decreases.

Senegambia & Niger -14.3%

Serbia +0.4% All changes were prior to 1903.

Seychelles +6.9% All changes were prior to QEII era and were all increases. Zil Elwannyen Sesel had no changes.

Shanghai no changes

Sharjah & Dependencies no changes

Siberia no changes

Sierra Leone +6.3% All changes, mostly increases, were prior to 1946.

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

27 Nov 2016
03:49:10pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Singapore -5.0% Many value changes, mostly down.

Slovakia -0.1%

Slovenia -0.2%

Solomon Islands +3.8% Most changes were before 1961.

Somalia -0.3% Most changes were before 1935.

Somali Coast / Afars and Issas / Djibuti -3.8% Somali Coast had many changes, mostly down. Afars and Issas was down. Djibuti increased.

Somaliland Protectorate +7.4%

South Africa +4.1% Changes were prior to 1950, especially definitive pairs. There were no changes in the back-of-book or the homelands.

South Arabia -5.3%

Southern Nigeria no changes

Southern Rhodesia +1.4%

South Georgia -9.8% Decreases were in the first definitive set.

South Russia -22.5%

South Sudan no stamps

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

28 Dec 2016
11:55:44am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

South West Africa / Namibia +1.5% South West Africa saw mixed changes that were mostly increases. Namibia had mixed changes that were mostly decreases.

Spain +1.1% Very few changes.

Spanish Guinea no changes

Spanish Morocco no changes

Spanish Sahara no changes

Spanish West Africa no changes

Ceylon / Sri Lanka +1.3% Ceylon had mostly increases up to 1910. Sri Lanka had very few changes, most of which were increases.

Stellaland no stamps from this area

Straits Settlements -0.1% All changes were in the 19th Century.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

05 Jan 2017
01:47:31am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Sudan +1.0% All changes were prior to 1935.

Surinam no changes

Swaziland +1.1%

Sweden -2.6% Prior to 1910 all changes were decreases. Some booklets prior to 1970 saw increases. Officials were down.

Switzerland no changes

Syria / Syrian Arab Government / United Arab Republic issues for Syria no changes

Tahiti no changes

Tajikistan no changes

Tanganyika +10.1% All changes, mostly increases, were prior to 1961.

Tannu Tuva -2.7% Air mail values decreased.

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

07 Jan 2017
11:50:31am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Tanzania +0.8%

Tete +27.2%


Thailand no changes

Thrace -0.6%

Tibet no changes

Timor +8.9%

Tobago +4.7%


Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

11 Jan 2017
11:09:02am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Togo -3.2% German era was down; British era had no changes; French era and the Republic era were mixed.

Tokelau -10.9% All changes were prior to 1971 and were down.

Tonga and Niuafo'ou had no changes

Transcaucasion Federated Republic no changes

Transvaal no changes

Trinidad +8.8%

Trinidad and Tobago +2.7%
King George V and VI were mostly up. QEII issues saw many changes, especially the definitive sets, with commemorative sets mostly down and the definitives mixed.

Tripolitania -1.8%

Tristan da Cunha -6.9%
Changes in the QEII era was mostly all down.

Trucial States -0.5%

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

13 Jan 2017
12:40:31am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Tunisia -7.0% Many changes, mostly down, up to the mid 1970s. After that, changes were mostly up, but there were not many of them.

Turkey +0.4% Only a small number of changes scattered throughout all the listings.

Turkey in Asia no changes

Turkish Cyprus +0.8% There were only a small number of changes, mostly increases.

Turkmenistan no changes

Turks and Caicos Islands +0.4% All changes were in the Victoria era.
Caicos Islands had no changes.

Turks Islands no changes

Tuvalu -0.5% No changes in the main listings, but islands were down slightly.

Ubangi-Shari -15.8% There were many changes, mostly all were decreases.

Like 
2 Members
like this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

15 Jan 2017
12:40:53am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Uganda +1.4% All changes, all increases, were in the Victoria era.

Ukraine no changes

Umm Al Qiwain no changes

United Arab Emirates no changes

Upper Senegal & Niger -17.0% There were large decreases in the first definitive set, and some small increases in the second.

Upper Silesia no changes

Uruguay -1.9% Changes from 1948-1962 were few, but were all increases. From 1963-1999 changes were mostly decreases, with many increases from the mid 1980s on. From 2000 on there were many large increases. Air Mails were mostly down. Many value changes, both increases and decreases, were 40% and more.

Uzbekistan no changes

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.
michael78651

16 Jan 2017
10:13:07am

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

New Hebrides (British) - Vanuatu +0.1% Vanuatu was unchanged.

Vatican City no changes

Venezuela -0.1%

Viet Nam -0.3%


Virgin Islands +1.6% All changes were in the Victoria era.

Wallis and Futuna Islands no changes

Western Ukraine no changes

Like
Login to Like
this post
michael78651

16 Jan 2017
09:18:19pm

re: 2015-2017 Scott Catalog Review - COMPLETED

Yemen no changes

Yemen People's Democratic Republic no changes

Yugoslavia +0.4% Value changes were all increases and were from 1937 through 1948 with a few changes in air mails. All other areas under Yugoslavia, including Trieste, locals, occupations, etc. had no changes.

Belgian Congo - Congo Democratic Republic - Zaire -4.0% All changes, mostly decreases, were in the Belgian Congo.

Zambezia +2.1%

Zambia -10.0%

Zanzibar -0.7%
Changes in the 19th Century were all increases. Changes from 1900 through 1936 were mostly decreases.

Rhodesia - Rhodesia & Nyasaland - Rhodesia State - Zimbabwe -0.9% Changes in the 19th Century were all increases. Changes in Rhodesia & Nyasaland were mostly decreases. Rhodesia State and Zimbabwe had no changes.

Zululand +3.2%


END OF VOLUME VI

Overall value change for Volume VI was +0.2%

END OF CATALOG REVIEW

Overall value change from 2015 catalogs to 2017 catalogs was +1.9%

Like
Login to Like
this post
        

Contact Webmaster | Visitors Online | Unsubscribe Emails | Facebook


User Agreement

Copyright © 2024 Stamporama.com