What we collect!

 

Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps
Discussion - Member to Member Sales - Research Center
Stamporama Discussion Board Logo
For People Who Love To Talk About Stamps



What we collect!
What we collect!


Sales, Swaps, Auction & Approvals/Approvals Disc. : Bigger Books?

 

Author
Postings
Soundcrest
Members Picture


27 Sep 2015
06:16:44am

Auctions - Approvals
Perhaps I am in the minority but I would like to see larger books than 24 pages and here is why. Personally I don't like mixing and matching countries in a book when you are doing it by price. For example, I have a book that contains 3 different German States, and in almost all cases the three are each represented on every page especially on the lower value pages. By having larger books the stamps could be separated out AND since there is a jump to box on the bottom (I just found this out), you could index the book in the book description so it could be set as say Page 1 Bavaria, Page 16 Baden, Page 29 Wurttemberg etc. If you don't index it, its your loss. The other reason to do this would be to allow the adding of pages. For example, say I have a book of 2 different French Colonies that has more than 50% sold. This creates a problem that I will deal with on another separate thread. If I want to add stamps to this book, for the most part the only way to do it is take it down, reorginize what is there, add another colony to it and put it back up. With larger indexed books, the extra colony could simply be added to the back and a notation made on the cover as to what the page numbers are for this new colony. The title of the book would also be changed. Just a thought I am throwing out there

Greg
Like
Login to Like
this post

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/soundcresthouse
michael78651

28 Sep 2015
10:01:49am
re: Bigger Books?

One problem with adding more pages and/or stamps to an existing book, is that it does not show up as a new book on the list. It is still still treated as an older book.

If I looked at your book list, I will see "new" besides all your books that I haven't looked at. If I look at your Greece book, that "new" will go away. If you add more stamps/pages to that book, the "new" will not reappear for that book.

I understand what you're saying, but while the approval books are a great thing, there are system limitations that cause some inconveniences with how the books can be compiled by sellers.

Like
Login to Like
this post
Soundcrest
Members Picture


28 Sep 2015
02:09:47pm

Auctions - Approvals
re: Bigger Books?

Michael you are correct on that, and if you did add more pages than you would have to a) change your description page to add an index so you could jump to a page number and b) promote it in the discussions. For example, I have a book of France in existence. Lets suppose the book has 75 stamps remaining and it has 24 pages. I have 50 Monaco MNH sets. I can't list them on my own, as there are not enough. I could take down the France book, add the Monaco scattered throughout the book on the appropriate price pages, and put it back up changing the title. If I did that, I could not honestly expect a person to page through a 24 page book looking for Monaco. On the other hand, with a larger book, I could add say 10 pages to the back of it for Monaco, keeping the pages separate by price, low to high, change the title and then put in the description Page 1-24 France MNH sets, Page 25-34 Monaco MNH Sets. A person could then jump to page 25 to view Moncao and not have to go through all the pages to hunt down the stamps. As with anything else, the seller has to be creating the books for the buyer's ease of use. Personally if I was looking for say German revenues, and I saw a 24 page book that said "Germany & Revenues" I probably would not page through the book looking for them. I don't think I'm alone in this. Put up a book that says Germany and Revenues and tell me what page they are on, yes, I'll look.
There may be as you say system limitations on this to be sure.

Like
Login to Like
this post

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/soundcresthouse
michael78651

28 Sep 2015
04:02:02pm
re: Bigger Books?

Greg, I do like your idea of "indexing". Not sure how you plan to do it, but my thought is to add the index on each page in the Comment section at the bottom.

Another reason why I wouldn't like the approval books be expandable to 35 pages is that I spend enough buying from each book that goes just to 24 pages! Big Grin

Like
Login to Like
this post
rrraphy
Members Picture


Retired Consultant APS#186030

28 Sep 2015
04:34:05pm
re: Bigger Books?

Greg:

"I have 50 Monaco MNH sets. I can't list them on my own, as there are not enough. : "


50 or so SETS would be allowed, as they fall under the exception to the 100 item rule in Approvals. Now not 50 sets of 1 (lol Big Grin ) but just like for covers, souvenir sheets, specialty items, and collections the rule for SETS is also relaxed.
Furthermore, the rule is also flexible for areas where 100 items is too much of a barrier. Think of some of the "dead countries" with just a few hundred stamps issued. If you had a book with less than 100, say...as an example...Alaouites...it would qualify under our exemption rule.
Remember folks, the rules are just a minimum "guideline". Now 50 stamps of a country with thousands of stamps issued would not pass mustard with me, but the intent is to have flexibility and help you ALL sell and buy, not make it impossible for some.
And if you have some doubts, message me.
Myself, I like bigger books, but not everyone does.
rrr...

Like
Login to Like
this post

"E. Rutherford: All science is either physics or stamp collecting."
Soundcrest
Members Picture


29 Sep 2015
10:59:41am

Auctions - Approvals
re: Bigger Books?

Thanks Ralph, though if I put up a book with only 50 sets at 7:00, I might make some enemies as too many people would miss out. I might be 3/4 gone by 7:05. I didn't realize you could get by with so few covers, though my first cover book will be closer to the 100 I think (unless the photos don't come out well. I really don't like smaller books myself, and I now find myself buying material to restock as well as making new.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/soundcresthouse
rrraphy
Members Picture


Retired Consultant APS#186030

29 Sep 2015
05:47:23pm
re: Bigger Books?

Greg: with our Approvals limitations of 24 pages, and if one puts 2 covers per page using the SOR templates, you max out at 48 items. So we adopted one of the exceptions to the 100 rule specifically to accommodate the bigger items such as covers, S/S, FDCs, and sets. I think any number above 25-30 would be fine..under...hum...may be pushing it from my viewpoint, and I will look at uniqueness. (and stay flexible)

The other exception is subject to the Moderator review, and is for stamp material (countries or topics, desirability or condition) where 100 items is just too much of a burden, due to rarity or other unique factors. (I definitely will not apply it to a book of Penny Black for exampleRolling On The Floor Laughing!)
We want to remain as inclusive as possible and encourage these in Approvals, not just confine the Books for the very low cost, or common items. On the other hand, Auctions is a more desirable place for them, so we will not allow books with too few items, especially if they are not grouped in a narrow collectible area.
rrr....

Like
Login to Like
this post

"E. Rutherford: All science is either physics or stamp collecting."
        

 

Author/Postings
Members Picture
Soundcrest

27 Sep 2015
06:16:44am

Auctions - Approvals

Perhaps I am in the minority but I would like to see larger books than 24 pages and here is why. Personally I don't like mixing and matching countries in a book when you are doing it by price. For example, I have a book that contains 3 different German States, and in almost all cases the three are each represented on every page especially on the lower value pages. By having larger books the stamps could be separated out AND since there is a jump to box on the bottom (I just found this out), you could index the book in the book description so it could be set as say Page 1 Bavaria, Page 16 Baden, Page 29 Wurttemberg etc. If you don't index it, its your loss. The other reason to do this would be to allow the adding of pages. For example, say I have a book of 2 different French Colonies that has more than 50% sold. This creates a problem that I will deal with on another separate thread. If I want to add stamps to this book, for the most part the only way to do it is take it down, reorginize what is there, add another colony to it and put it back up. With larger indexed books, the extra colony could simply be added to the back and a notation made on the cover as to what the page numbers are for this new colony. The title of the book would also be changed. Just a thought I am throwing out there

Greg

Like
Login to Like
this post

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/sou ...
michael78651

28 Sep 2015
10:01:49am

re: Bigger Books?

One problem with adding more pages and/or stamps to an existing book, is that it does not show up as a new book on the list. It is still still treated as an older book.

If I looked at your book list, I will see "new" besides all your books that I haven't looked at. If I look at your Greece book, that "new" will go away. If you add more stamps/pages to that book, the "new" will not reappear for that book.

I understand what you're saying, but while the approval books are a great thing, there are system limitations that cause some inconveniences with how the books can be compiled by sellers.

Like
Login to Like
this post
Members Picture
Soundcrest

28 Sep 2015
02:09:47pm

Auctions - Approvals

re: Bigger Books?

Michael you are correct on that, and if you did add more pages than you would have to a) change your description page to add an index so you could jump to a page number and b) promote it in the discussions. For example, I have a book of France in existence. Lets suppose the book has 75 stamps remaining and it has 24 pages. I have 50 Monaco MNH sets. I can't list them on my own, as there are not enough. I could take down the France book, add the Monaco scattered throughout the book on the appropriate price pages, and put it back up changing the title. If I did that, I could not honestly expect a person to page through a 24 page book looking for Monaco. On the other hand, with a larger book, I could add say 10 pages to the back of it for Monaco, keeping the pages separate by price, low to high, change the title and then put in the description Page 1-24 France MNH sets, Page 25-34 Monaco MNH Sets. A person could then jump to page 25 to view Moncao and not have to go through all the pages to hunt down the stamps. As with anything else, the seller has to be creating the books for the buyer's ease of use. Personally if I was looking for say German revenues, and I saw a 24 page book that said "Germany & Revenues" I probably would not page through the book looking for them. I don't think I'm alone in this. Put up a book that says Germany and Revenues and tell me what page they are on, yes, I'll look.
There may be as you say system limitations on this to be sure.

Like
Login to Like
this post

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/sou ...
michael78651

28 Sep 2015
04:02:02pm

re: Bigger Books?

Greg, I do like your idea of "indexing". Not sure how you plan to do it, but my thought is to add the index on each page in the Comment section at the bottom.

Another reason why I wouldn't like the approval books be expandable to 35 pages is that I spend enough buying from each book that goes just to 24 pages! Big Grin

Like
Login to Like
this post
Members Picture
rrraphy

Retired Consultant APS#186030
28 Sep 2015
04:34:05pm

re: Bigger Books?

Greg:

"I have 50 Monaco MNH sets. I can't list them on my own, as there are not enough. : "


50 or so SETS would be allowed, as they fall under the exception to the 100 item rule in Approvals. Now not 50 sets of 1 (lol Big Grin ) but just like for covers, souvenir sheets, specialty items, and collections the rule for SETS is also relaxed.
Furthermore, the rule is also flexible for areas where 100 items is too much of a barrier. Think of some of the "dead countries" with just a few hundred stamps issued. If you had a book with less than 100, say...as an example...Alaouites...it would qualify under our exemption rule.
Remember folks, the rules are just a minimum "guideline". Now 50 stamps of a country with thousands of stamps issued would not pass mustard with me, but the intent is to have flexibility and help you ALL sell and buy, not make it impossible for some.
And if you have some doubts, message me.
Myself, I like bigger books, but not everyone does.
rrr...

Like
Login to Like
this post

"E. Rutherford: All science is either physics or stamp collecting."
Members Picture
Soundcrest

29 Sep 2015
10:59:41am

Auctions - Approvals

re: Bigger Books?

Thanks Ralph, though if I put up a book with only 50 sets at 7:00, I might make some enemies as too many people would miss out. I might be 3/4 gone by 7:05. I didn't realize you could get by with so few covers, though my first cover book will be closer to the 100 I think (unless the photos don't come out well. I really don't like smaller books myself, and I now find myself buying material to restock as well as making new.

Like 
1 Member
likes this post.
Login to Like.

"Stamps Postcards Sheet Music Books and More! See something you like contact me!"

www.ebay.com/str/sou ...
Members Picture
rrraphy

Retired Consultant APS#186030
29 Sep 2015
05:47:23pm

re: Bigger Books?

Greg: with our Approvals limitations of 24 pages, and if one puts 2 covers per page using the SOR templates, you max out at 48 items. So we adopted one of the exceptions to the 100 rule specifically to accommodate the bigger items such as covers, S/S, FDCs, and sets. I think any number above 25-30 would be fine..under...hum...may be pushing it from my viewpoint, and I will look at uniqueness. (and stay flexible)

The other exception is subject to the Moderator review, and is for stamp material (countries or topics, desirability or condition) where 100 items is just too much of a burden, due to rarity or other unique factors. (I definitely will not apply it to a book of Penny Black for exampleRolling On The Floor Laughing!)
We want to remain as inclusive as possible and encourage these in Approvals, not just confine the Books for the very low cost, or common items. On the other hand, Auctions is a more desirable place for them, so we will not allow books with too few items, especially if they are not grouped in a narrow collectible area.
rrr....

Like
Login to Like
this post

"E. Rutherford: All science is either physics or stamp collecting."
        

Contact Webmaster | Visitors Online | Unsubscribe Emails | Facebook


User Agreement

Copyright © 2024 Stamporama.com